Oxbridge Essays Experts or AI: Who Writes Better Essays?

We’ve carried out a side-by-side evaluation of essays produced by our expert academics and AI-written essays, generated by the latest ChatGPT model. Both parties completed identical assignments, which were then independently and blindly assessed by an academic marker. Each example includes a detailed marking report, with an expected grade and feedback highlighting the key strengths and weaknesses of both outputs.

Academic Expert and AI Assignments Compared

  • Undergraduate Essay, Politics, 1000 Words

    To what extent do conservatives agree about paternalism?

    Created using AI (ChatGPT)

    • Structure
    • Argument
    • Sources
    • Knowledge
    • Style
    Grade
    48–52%

    Completed by an Oxbridge Essays Expert in Politics

    • Structure
    • Argument
    • Sources
    • Knowledge
    • Style
    Grade
    69–73%
  • Undergraduate Essay, Business, 1000 Words

    The role of government regulation in promoting ethical business practices: balancing sustainability and economic growth

    Created using AI (ChatGPT)

    • Structure
    • Argument
    • Sources
    • Knowledge
    • Style
    Grade
    43–47%

    Completed by an Oxbridge Essays Expert in Business

    • Structure
    • Argument
    • Sources
    • Knowledge
    • Style
    Grade
    62–66%

Why AI Fails at Writing Your Essays

Are AI essay writing tools really capable of producing high-quality academic work? The short answer is no. Using AI for essay writing might seem convenient, but AI-generated essays pose significant limitations, ranging from weak arguments to unreliable or fabricated sources and a lack of critical thinking. Is it really worth the risk?

AI Lacks Critical Thinking

At the heart of academic writing lies critical engagement with existing scholarly sources, aiming to develop a unique, unbiased framework as a foundation for your own research. While AI can summarise, it cannot engage in true critical analysis. So, can you really rely on an AI tool to build solid arguments for your research focus? For well-structured, academically sound work, only trust highly qualified academics who bring the expertise and critical thinking your research deserves.

academic library

High Risk of Plagiarism

How can you be certain that your AI-generated essay is presenting accurate arguments if AI tools are never entirely up to date, and even prone to fabricating sources to back up their claims? Fact-checking, along with attributing authority to avoid plagiarism issues, should always be a priority when writing any academic piece. AI-written essays might appear polished at first glance, but they contain false information, made-up citations, and even plagiarism. While AI won’t check facts, your university certainly will, and the consequences can be severe.

student concluding her dissertation

AI Produces Generic Work

A collection of facts alone is not enough to develop a well-articulated essay—and yet, that’s precisely what you get when you rely on AI essay writing tools. A strong essay should demonstrate an understanding of the subject through nuanced argumentation and backed-up claims. But without the ability to engage with sources, AI will only produce generic summaries, foregoing the latest research. In contrast, an expert academic dedicates time to selecting relevant sources, and analyses them with a critical lens to construct well-supported arguments.

zoom collaboration

The Unique Value of Our Academics

The level of expertise and critical thinking our academics bring to each assignment goes far beyond what AI can achieve. With only 4% of applicants passing our rigorous selection process, you’ll be working with the brightest minds from top universities, including Oxbridge. It won’t be a passive process: your academic will collaborate with you through Zoom, offering subject-specific support tailored to your needs.

Download Real Examples from Our Academics

Browse examples of work produced by Oxbridge Essays' academics and discover the level of quality you can expect when you place an order with us.

How We Guarantee 100% Original Work

Whether it’s a dissertation, a thesis, or an essay, we guarantee that the work you receive will meet the standards required by your university. Expect meticulously researched and academically sound content that is 100% plagiarism-free and AI-free.

800+ Top UK Academics

Your dedicated academic, selected from our network of 800+ professionals from the UK’s most prestigious universities and top institutions worldwide, will conduct in-depth research and use their expertise to produce work tailored to your requirements.

15-Step Quality Control Process

Every order undergoes a rigorous 15-step quality control process, from fact-checking to citation verification. We also conduct advanced AI and plagiarism scans to confirm its authenticity and originality.

Peace of Mind with Every Order

Our multi-tiered quality control process ensures that your assignment is 100% original and free from errors. But if you’re not fully satisfied, you have 10 days to request free alterations. We’ll work with you until you’re completely happy with the final result.

What Students Are Saying About Oxbridge Essays

Since 2006, we've helped tens of thousands of students with expertly written essays, dissertations, and many other assignments. Discover why students trust our top-tier academics for personalised support.

I had a couple of problems when writing my methodology chapter, and the staff went above and beyond to find a solution. The job was completed on time and to the desired standard.

A, Undergraduate Student

The scope of knowledge and the delivery of the model papers are unparalleled and at times exceed the requirements not to mention the expected grade. A great service from a dedicated and helpful team.

Jason, Undergraduate Student

The essay was written in a coherent manner as per my request and the staff were very helpful and accommodating. Great research, amazing style and brilliant arguments. I would wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone.

Jack, Undergraduate Student

4.8 out of 5 based on
368 genuine customer reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you guarantee that your academics are not using AI to write my essay?

We can guarantee that every project is completed by our carefully vetted human academics, not AI. Each order undergoes a meticulous, 15-step quality control process, and we also use advanced software to ensure no part of the work is AI-generated. For extra peace of mind, you can purchase an AI scan of your document as an add-on service when placing your order.

Which universities do you source your academics from?

Our network includes academics from some of the top institutions in the UK. While many of our academics have attended Oxford and Cambridge, we also collaborate with professionals from leading red-brick UK universities and many prestigious institutions in London such as Imperial College London and King’s College London. Additionally, we work with academics from top Ivy League universities, such as Harvard or Yale, in the US. Discover more about how we select our academics.

Can I view other examples of work written by real academics?

Yes, we offer a selection of writing examples by our expert academics, including essays, full dissertations, reports, literature reviews, and more, available for you to view and download. These examples showcase the high quality of work you can expect when you order with us, they reflect critical thinking and the customisation that our experts bring to every single project, unlike AI-generated assignments which lack depth. They’re also a great resource to inspire your own writing.

Choose Our Academics’ Expertise for Your University Journey

Don’t risk compromising your grades by taking AI shortcuts. Instead, partner with us to make sure that your work is unique, original and meets the highest standards.